| Ari Beachey | Decides to make their gap year a gap decade and spends it hitchhiking around the world, protesting for the rights of people wherever they go. |
| Jake Bedwell | Sells all of his shoes for charity and becomes a shoeless monk. |
| Tessa Clark | Decides her true interest lies in women’s rugby and quits volleyball to join the National Rugby League. |
| Megan Duckworth | Takes her love of art to the next level by getting a full body tattoo. |
| Jacob Gonsalves | Is mistaken for a Tarsier and gets locked up in a zoo. |
| Abby Hochstetler | Decides pre-med is too difficult and decides to get a job at a flower sanctuary. |
| Carissa Hostetler | Moves to Japan, takes over, and rules as a dictator with her 27 cats. |
| Simon Hurst | Grows his hair out even further, dyes it blonde, and gets a job at Disney as Rapunzel. |
| Jackson King | Is hired to sketch out plans for the remodel of the White House gardens, involving as many trees as possible. |
| Sarah Leininger | Dyes her hair red and stars in the live action version of Brave as Princess Merida. |
| Byeong Min Lim | Opens a sloth sanctuary and hires workers to run it while he naps with the sloths. |
| Joe Liu | Becomes a famous drummer in a death metal band. |
| Derick Masatu | Moves back to Tanzania and opens a giraffe pet store. |
| Khalid Miller | Creates his own trading card game and becomes a billionaire. |
| Lane Miller | Can be found roaming the aisles of Wal-Mart, serenading girls with his saxophone skills. |
| Sophie Miller | Creates her own TV show and yells at the contestants in a Gordon Ramsey like fashion. |
| Samantha Minaya | Realizes public speaking is all about volume and gets a job yelling GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAALLLLL on televised soccer matches. |
| Natan Nafziger | Moves to Brazil, realizes he actually can’t speak Portuguese. |
| Brandon Nguyen | Writes a best selling book about how rice is life. |
| Erick Ortiz | Makes millions being a radio DJ, but loses it all after investing in bad stocks. |
| Pamela Ortiz | Decides she hates Goshen and everything associated with it and moves to San Francisco, California |
| Jeremiah Overman | Becomes a world famous body builder. |
| Joel Plank | Starts up a business where he gets to test beds by sleeping on them all day. |
| Daniel Robles | Invents a video game which earns him millions, but he spends it all purchasing massive sombreros from gift shops all over the world. |
| Sofia Thomas | Becomes a politician solely to advocate for the legalization of polygamous relationships. |
| Maggie Wang | Takes up a career in makeup and becomes a morgue cosmetologist. |
| Brooke Weaver | Creates a support group called Laughter Anonymous for people who find almost everything funny. |
| Jiwoo Wi | Realizes she hates talking, becomes a recluse, and never leaves her house. |
| Carissa Woolace | Realizes she hates small children, gives up elementary education, and becomes a dietician. |
| Hannah Yeakey | Decides to completely give up being a vegetarian and begins eating a McDonald’s Big Mac for every meal. |
| CJ Zmudzinski | Decides working in a museum isn’t actually that fun and decides to break into them instead to build her own collection. |
| Zane Zmudzinski | Gives up fishing, takes up knitting. |
~Carissa Woolace